UK - Discretionary powers of pension trustees run counter to what modern society expects, ombudsman David Laverick believes.
Trustees currently have the power to decide issues - benefits for unmarried partners, for example - arbitrarily without the requirement to explain how they came to their decision.
Laverick noted his surprise that some case law may well sit uneasily behind modern day expectations, particularly in cases of the discretionary powers of trustees.
Laverick said: “Pension trustees do not need to give any reasons for the exercise of their discretionary powers and that seems to generally run counter to what modern society expects.
If people are taking decisions that might effect them they expect to have a reasoned explanation for these.”
His comments enforce those made by industry experts who have voiced concern that pensions legislation is too archaic and complicated.
Laverick was keen to endorse the government’s pensions simplifications initiative, unveiled last month which is headed by former NAPF chairman Alan Pickering.
Laverick said: “I support the idea of simplifying pensions [legislation] and we will be making representation to the simplification review .”
The ombudsman confirmed that he had not had to deal with any determination where the issue of discretionary trustee powers had been a factor, and concluded by revealing a central tenet of his philosophy as the ombudsman. He said: “I start from a premise that good administration requires a reasoned decision.”
By Jonathan Stapleton
Royal London saw its new group pension business decline over the first half of 2018 as the rollout of auto-enrolment (AE) drew to a close, according to its interim results.
Now Pensions has made "huge progress" in resolving legacy administration issues - switching systems and completing unit adjustment for a "large proportion" of members, it says.
Trustees of the Airways Pension Scheme (APS) will not make a firm decision on whether to appeal the Court of Appeal's judgment on discretionary increase payments until September.
Accountant Hashmukh Shah has pleaded guilty to deliberately providing false information to The Pensions Regulator (TPR) when stating a pension scheme had been set up for staff of a London-based restaurant.