The UK Law Commission's review of the issue of pension scheme surplus will cause damage and uncertainty to pension schemes, according to industry experts.
The Treasury has said it will request the Law Commission to consider a law on surplus this autumn. But both the National Association of Pension Funds (NAPF) and the Association of Pension Lawyers (APL) have urged the Law Commission not to go ahead with the review.
APL chairman Robert West said: “There is a concern that even the referral to the Law Commission will create uncertainty among employers and trustees, irrespective of the conclusion that the law commission reaches.
“We do not want to go through a period of further uncertainty, particularly when case law has pretty much answered most of the outstanding questions referring to surplus.”
The APL wants the government to let the findings of the 1993 Goode Committee report to stand. This concluded that surplus should be left up to the rules of each individual pension scheme.
West further stated that he believed it was the minority of pension schemes that had unclear surplus rules that might subsequently generate court action.
J Sainsbury pensions manager Geof Pearson said: “I think it is very dangerous territory, it could do more damage than good.
“If the members think the surplus is theirs, all it has the effect of doing is undermining the employers’ commitment to that scheme, so it is an ephemeral victory.”
Bacon & Woodrow investment practice associate Michael Robarts said: “If anybody owns the surplus it is the trustees and they have a duty to act reasonably to both the beneficiaries and the plan sponsor.”
Robarts proposed an independent assessment of scheme value as a way of working out who owns surplus.
He added: “This is a good moment to be having this debate, as there are not too many contribution holidays taking place at the moment which would otherwise make it emotive.” By David Rowley
The secretary of state for work and pensions has told MPs clawback and avoidance measures could be imposed for the people responsible for driving Carillion over the cliff.
Occupational pension provision has continued to grow in value, but there remains large variance in incomes across the pensioner age group, according to latest government data.
Defined benefit (DB) schemes could have an aggregate surplus by 2021 under Pension Protection Fund (PPF) projections, its strategic plan for 2018 to 2021 reveals.
Investment consultants are failing to recommend products that outperform net of fees, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has said as its investigation into the market continues.