US - Detroit workers' pension boards have sued Michigan Governor Rick Snyder, asking a court to declare unconstitutional a new law granting state-appointed financial managers emergency powers to terminate employee contracts and suspend collective bargaining.
Snyder said the law, signed on March 16, would help keep Michigan communities out of bankruptcy. Michigan has emergency managers running the schools in Detroit, as well as the cities of Pontiac, Ecorse and Benton Harbor.
The law would "impermissibly modify the Detroit city charter and various collective bargaining agreements between the city of Detroit and its uniformed and non-uniformed workers," the pension boards said in the lawsuit filed in federal court in Detroit. The law authorises "the modification and termination of constitutionally protected contract rights and the seizure of control of retirement systems," according to the complaint.
The pension boards, which also named the Michigan treasurer as a defendant, asked for a court order blocking the law from taking effect. The complaint was filed yesterday by the General Retirement System of the City of Detroit, the Police and Fire Retirement System, and four individuals, including the chairs of both boards.
The Detroit pension funds have "performed in the top 20% of municipal pension funds nationwide in recent years," despite "the recent global economic meltdown," they said in the complaint.
Tigi Habtemariam, Snyder's spokeswoman, didn't immediately return a call for comment.
PP has analysed the accounts of the biggest pension consulting firms and recorded the turnover (revenue) in their most recent accounts. The full leaderboard is below…
UK defined benefit (DB) schemes have increasingly undertaken benefit reviews over the last four years resulting in an acceleration of scheme closures, Aon research finds.
Contributions are no longer sufficient to meet regular payments for three-quarters of small- to medium- sized defined benefit (DB) schemes, Buck analysis finds.