Is the argument for a collective 'pot-for-life' becoming more compelling?

Ruari Grant says collective pensions need continuity to work at their best for members

clock • 4 min read
Ruari Grant: In Australia, where pots are stapled to individuals and follow them between employers, admin hurdles to pot-follows-member have been overcome
Image:

Ruari Grant: In Australia, where pots are stapled to individuals and follow them between employers, admin hurdles to pot-follows-member have been overcome

This week concludes government’s consultation on consolidating existing small DC pots, and the policy folk among us will be diligently submitting comments on every element of technical detail. But how many of those responses will look further ahead, and consider bolder ideas about what happens once we start to get on top of the backlog of pots?

Granted this is a consultation on regulations, not policy, but that shouldn't stop us examining how we address the root cause of this problem, which creates one million sub-£1k pots every year.

Ambitious policy reform isn't always lavished with praise; you need look no further than the torrents of criticism and political sparring about government's guided retirement plans over the last week. But that mustn't prevent us considering what might come next, inconvenient or otherwise.  

So in a week we're talking about small ‘pot' consolidation, let's not overlook the impact this fragmentation could create in a collective pensions world.

While in DC each job change creates pot complexity and inefficiency, with collective pensions, it also undermines the continuity which is so appealing in the model.

Collective schemes are designed to build a retirement income, and they work best when members participate over long periods, benefiting from collective investment in growth assets, longevity pooling and the smoothing of outcomes through time.

That sits uneasily alongside a labour market where people move jobs regularly.

Changing jobs can force collective pension members into schemes with different rules and retirement strategies, disrupting a long-term path to income. The previous government considered pot-for-life in 2023, but its interaction with collective pensions was largely overlooked.

With the expected first whole-life multi-employer collective schemes launching in 2027, is the argument for a collective pension-for-life becoming more compelling?

The employer

Crucially, this is not an argument against employer choice. As we know, the decision makers in our current system are employers, not members.

But while in a future world, employers may have little to distinguish between at-scale master trusts, the growth of collective pensions will depend heavily on them. Indeed, engaged and paternalistic employers wanting to help employees achieve better retirement outcomes, but unable to sustain DB, are becoming collective pensions' strongest advocates. This is a middle ground, giving employers access to a pension that targets retirement income while maintaining cost certainty.

A collective pot-for-life model could preserve the role of employers while giving members greater continuity. Employers would continue to select, sponsor and promote high-quality pension provision. They would continue to make contributions and play a critical role in driving participation. But members would – perhaps via an opt-out system – be able to continue accruing a pension with the same scheme they are familiar with, uninterrupted.

This continuity would mean more predictability over target income in retirement, compared to a collection of pots and incomes, which would be more difficult to understand, creating a dependency on advisors or financial models.

The challenges

As with anything worth doing, this isn't easy. And it would require significant payroll and administrative changes.

Employers would need to send contributions to multiple providers rather than just one, albeit there will be far fewer of these in future. New clearing-house infrastructure may be required to route contributions efficiently and maintain data quality. These challenges should not be dismissed, but administrative hurdles should not stifle innovation, and if we began the pot-for-life journey with collective pensions, the number of scheme connections necessary would be lower, reducing initial complexity.

More important are the concerns around consumer choice and the risk of savers becoming attached to underperforming schemes. Such a system could only work where relevant schemes meet consistently high value for money (VfM) standards, and where members receive clear, engaging information on all options when changing job. All of us need to help government work up a fair and meaningful means of assessing VfM for collective schemes.

Most of the administrative hurdles have been overcome elsewhere though, most notably in Australia, where pots are stapled to individuals and follow them between employers. A key difference down under is that much the operational heavy lifting is done centrally by their tax office – something that must at least warrant some more investigation here, despite the inevitable HMRC reluctance.

The question for policymakers is therefore whether it's time to tackle the operational complexity to deliver retirement continuity in a fragmented labour market, while complementing concurrent priorities on sustainable incomes and productive investment.

For collective pensions, I'll provocatively suggest the answer could be yes. Right now, our heads may be buried in the next five years of reforms, but if we want pensions to follow people through life, we cannot keep letting every new job reset the journey.

Ruari Grant is head of policy and external affairs at TPT Retirement Solutions

More on Collective Defined Contribution

TPT submits multi-employer CDC scheme authorisation application to TPR

TPT submits multi-employer CDC scheme authorisation application to TPR

Provider becomes first to submit application to the regulator in ‘major milestone’

Alex Levy
clock 04 November 2026 • 2 min read
CDC success will depend on alignment on trade-offs

CDC success will depend on alignment on trade-offs

Support is building in the market, but employer doubts around complexity remain

Alex Levy
clock 16 October 2026 • 2 min read
CDC schemes at 'tipping point' as employers mull option

CDC schemes at 'tipping point' as employers mull option

Panel says ‘bigger employers’ will be central in the future development of CDC schemes

Martin Richmond
clock 14 October 2026 • 3 min read
Trustpilot