Aon

Bulk member option exercises: What are the benefits for schemes and members?

clock • 1 min read

Industry Voice: Over the past three years, sponsors and trustees have been navigating their way through the pension freedoms and trying to predict what impact they will have on their pension schemes.

Over this time, we have seen a huge increase in demand from sponsors and trustees alike in running bulk member options exercises where members are informed of options available to them - both within and outside of the pension scheme - and given independent financial advice to help them understand those options.

Such exercises typically include bulk transfer value exercises (with or without an enhancement) and pension increase exchange exercises.

To enhance or not to enhance?

When looking at transfer value exercises in particular, potentially the two most important considerations are:

 1.       Whether transfer values are sufficiently attractive for members to want to transfer out of the pension scheme; and

2.       Whether transfer values are sufficiently attractive for members to want to transfer out of the pension scheme now.

If the focus is on maximising risk and liability reduction in the short term, the second point becomes crucial. In this scenario, the decision of whether to offer members an enhancement to their transfer value comes into play.

In the exercises Aon has led since 2015, around half have offered members enhancements, and those exercises have seen more than double the level of transferring members on average.

Our statistics tell us that even a small enhancement can have a noticeable impact on the outcomes of an exercise.

To read the full article and gain access to Aon's Guide to Member Options, click here.

Oliver Cowan is a senior consultant at Aon.

More on Defined Benefit

Historical analysis key to DB surplus allocation, says Hymans

Historical analysis key to DB surplus allocation, says Hymans

Analysis of past contribution split can provide an objective basis for negotiations

Alex Levy
clock 06 August 2026 • 3 min read
Schemes urged to stop treating buyout as automatic default

Schemes urged to stop treating buyout as automatic default

SPP report suggests schemes should take ‘objective-led’ approach to endgame planning

Holly Roach
clock 06 August 2026 • 1 min read
Partner Insight: Growing the retirement orchard – making sense of CDC

Partner Insight: Growing the retirement orchard – making sense of CDC

BlackRock's Massi Delle Donne explains how CDC could bear greater fruit for pension savers

Massi Delle Donne, Managing Director Institutional Solutions EMEA @ BlackRock
clock 23 July 2026 • 4 min read
Trustpilot