Partner Insight - Over half of trustees still appointing incumbent consultants - despite new CMA rules

clock • 1 min read

 

Fiduciary management is a crucial tool for many pension scheme trustees. But concerns over the competitiveness of this market and the effect that could have on member outcomes has grown in recent years.

Professional Pensions research, conducted in association with Goldman Sachs Asset Management, demonstrates a similar story; with over half of trustees in our survey opting to appoint their incumbent investment consultant as fiduciary manager, rather than going through a more complex tender process.

Of course, that's not an issue in itself, assuming that tender processes have been conducted openly, competitively and rigorously.

Our research, however, shows that this is not always true, and that trustees appointing their incumbent consultant tend to run less rigorous selections.

We spoke to trustees and third-party experts for their view on the subject in this video, as we delve into our research results.

More on Investment

ICSWG launches climate investing framework

ICSWG launches climate investing framework

Framework will assist investors in decision making to support real-world change

Martin Richmond
clock 07 January 2026 • 2 min read
ESG progress stalls across UK fiduciary management market

ESG progress stalls across UK fiduciary management market

Just 21% of fiduciary managers were rated ‘green’ in 2025, down from 38% last year

Jonathan Stapleton
clock 07 January 2026 • 2 min read
FM fees for smaller schemes plateau amid cost inflation and falling asset values

FM fees for smaller schemes plateau amid cost inflation and falling asset values

Latest EY survey also shows shift towards internal fund management

Jonathan Stapleton
clock 06 January 2026 • 4 min read
Trustpilot