• Home
  • Admin/Tech
  • Benefits
  • Buzz
  • DB
  • DC
  • Diversity
  • Investment
  • Law & regulation
  • Risk reduction
  • Events
  • Whitepapers
  • Spotlights
  • Digital Edition
  • PPTV
  • Newsletters
  • Sign in
  •  
      • Newsletters
      • Account details
      • Contact support
      • Sign out
     
    •  

      You are currently accessing ProfessionalPensions via your Enterprise account.

      If you already have an account please use the link below to sign in.

      If you have any problems with your access or would like to request an individual access account please contact our customer service team.

      Phone: +44 (0) 1858 438800

      Email: [email protected]

      • Sign in
  • Follow us
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • Newsletters
    • YouTube
  • Register
  • Subscribe
  • Events
    • Upcoming events
      event logo
      WSB Webinar: Tackling financial wellbeing in the workplace

      This webinar will explore how employers can help employees take control of their finances through the provision of financial education and guidance. It will look at how such financial education programmes should be delivered to ensure maximum engagement as well as the content such offerings should include.

      • Date: 23 Feb 2021
      • Webinar
      event logo
      Webinar - LGIM Climate Solutions: how we measure climate risk and alignment in investors’ portfolios

      As investors move to incorporate a greater focus on climate change into their portfolios, there is an increasing requirement to be able to quantify and report on the climate credentials of investments and to what extent they are aligned with the goals of the Paris Agreement.In this webinar, LGIM explain how they quantify portfolio alignment with the Paris goals, using a combination of historical and forward-looking measures.

      • Date: 24 Feb 2021
      • Webinar
      event logo
      Admin & Data Forum 2021

      This concise half-day event will explore a variety of different issues affecting scheme managers, through a combination of informative presentations and interactive panel debates, including GMP equalisation, the pensions dashboard, the accuracy and quality of members data and the latest trends in scheme administration.

      • Date: 04 Mar 2021
      event logo
      Defined Benefit Consolidation Conference

      Professional Pensions is hosting this concise digital event on the 25th March to provide a crucial update on where the current regulation stands on DB Consolidators, assess the different models available, what the expected funding levels are and the governance requirements. This event will be a combination of short presentations followed by live Q&A’s with our expert speakers allowing plenty of time to answer your questions.

      • Date: 25 Mar 2021
      • Digital Conference
      View all events
      Follow our Professional Pension Events

      Sign up to receive email alerts about our events

      Sign up

  • Whitepapers
    • How DC schemes can gain exposure to different asset classes in a low-return environment

      So far, DC plans have largely been focused on the onset of auto-enrolment and changes to the regulatory framework - be it the ‘charge cap,' ‘pension freedoms' or consultations around ‘value for money', says Annabel Tonry, Executive Director at J.P. Morgan Asset Management (JPMAM).

      Download
      Pension freedoms three years on

      In 2015 George Osborne, then the UK Chancellor of the Exchequer, decided that those age over 55 could take much more of their pension in cash. This has since opened up a range of possibilities for DC scheme members in the world of pensions.

      Download
      Find whitepapers
      Search by title or subject area
      View all whitepapers
  • Spotlights
  • Digital Edition
Professional Pensions
Professional Pensions
  • Home
  • Admin/Tech
  • Benefits
  • Buzz
  • DB
  • DC
  • Diversity
  • Investment
  • Law & regulation
  • Risk reduction
 
    • Newsletters
    • Account details
    • Contact support
    • Sign out
 
  •  

    You are currently accessing ProfessionalPensions via your Enterprise account.

    If you already have an account please use the link below to sign in.

    If you have any problems with your access or would like to request an individual access account please contact our customer service team.

    Phone: +44 (0) 1858 438800

    Email: [email protected]

    • Sign in
  • Investment

FCA interim market study shines spotlight on investment consultants

FCA interim market study shines spotlight on investment consultants
  • Helen Morrissey
  • Helen Morrissey
  • @PensionsHelen
  • 21 November 2016
  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  
0 Comments

At a glance

  • The FCA is to consult on whether to make a market investigation reference on the market to the Competition and Markets Authority.
  • The report found that while investment consultants undertake valuable due diligence for pension funds, they are not effective at identifying outperforming fund managers.
  • Difficulties were also found in clients being able to assess and monitor their investment consultant. 

The interim findings of the FCA's Asset Management Market Study highlight concerns about the investment consulting market's transparency. Helen Morrissey takes a look at the findings.

Interim findings of The Financial Conduct Authority's (FCA) Asset Management Market Study showed concerns over the lack of competition and transparency in the investment consultancy market.

In the findings published on 18 November the FCA announced it is to consult on whether to make a market investigation reference on the market to the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA). This is the first time the regulator has exercised this power.

Related articles

  • Green gilts to become 'one stop shop' for scheme needs despite 'greenium' and 'greenwashing' fears
  • 2021 outlook: What's next for scheme governance?
  • 2021 outlook: What's next for regulation?
  • 2021 outlook: What's next for ESG?

The study also contains a recommendation that the provision of institutional investment advice is to be regulated by FCA.

The report found the market to be heavily concentrated, with 60% of market share being taken up by three firms: Aon Hewitt, Mercer and Willis Towers Watson.

Despite the range of consultancy firms operating in the market, the study showed that 91% of investors have not switched consultants in the last five years. While the process of switching consultants was neither difficult nor costly, respondents said the time and resources needed for a tender process acted as a deterrent.

Punter Southall head of investment consulting Danny Vassiliades called the report "an important and necessary review" and welcomed the recommendation to the CMA.

"There is a clear requirement for more competition in the investment consulting market. Currently, the industry is dominated by three large providers," he said. "We believe this has a number of negative consequences for pension schemes and the market more widely."

He added: "Schemes can get a great service from any number of consultancy firms and there is certainly no restriction on good consultants out there."

Aon Hewitt head of UK investment consulting Tim Giles also welcomed the review but disputed the idea that the dominance of three providers was a negative: "We welcome anything that improves both the competitiveness of the market and the outcomes clients receive," he said. "We do make up a large part of the consulting market but we are in this position because people want to work with us. There are a large number of companies operating within this area and there are no real barriers to clients moving if they wish to."

Measuring performance

According to the report, while investment consultants undertake valuable due diligence for pension funds, they are not effective at identifying outperforming fund managers.

Difficulties were also found in clients being able to assess and monitor their investment consultant. This was seen to be a particular issue for smaller pension schemes.

According to the report, the information presented "was at times difficult to understand and important factors were not always highlighted. This could lead to poor performance not being communicated or being easily disguised."

However, LCP partner James Trask believes it is difficult to publish information showing the success of advice given: "It is a challenge to publish information to show how successful your advice has been as there is no standardised way of doing this," he says. "The adviser may not even be the one who makes the final decision. The client could make a decision that wasn't the adviser's choice. It is easier to monitor in something like fiduciary management where the decision is made by the consultant but otherwise it will be difficult."

According to the regulator, providing schemes with clearer information will put trustees in a better position to challenge their consultants where necessary.

Commenting on the report, the FCA's executive director of strategy and competition Christopher Woolard said: "The principal issue here is that, from a legal point of view, trustees are reliant on their consultant's advice. They need to have the necessary information to be able to push back and challenge the advice they receive where necessary."

However, Vassiliades says that schemes regardless of size are challenging their consultants and that it is something to be welcomed: "We do get challenged by our clients, regardless of their size, which is vital in ensuring schemes know they are getting value from the advice you provide. It may be the case that larger schemes may have more expertise and so might challenge a bit more but we recognise challenge from schemes of all sizes."

Fiduciary management

The report also highlights concerns around the adoption of fiduciary management by consultants. While the report identifies that a firm recommending its own in-house fiduciary management survey was not necessarily problematic, there was an incentive for consultants to recommend such a service even when a client might be better served by another model or provider.

Some asset managers also highlighted the conflict of interest this model brings. Some said they were concerned they had to share the details of their products with the investment consultant to receive a rating. However, the investment consultant could then take those ideas and use them to develop their own product.

Cardano head of clients Richard Dowell believes the report could really help the industry to move towards a more transparent way of doing things: "It is good to see the FCA has listened to the industry and made a number of positive statements especially around fiduciary management where there is an ongoing lack of transparency around fees and performance."

He continued: "We would like to see a standard being developed and I would dispute anyone that says this is too difficult to do. We have published our track record for several years and if we can do this then the others can as well." 

The interim findings of the FCA's report show the regulator is willing to take a thorough look at whether the investment consultancy market is working in the right way for its users. It will be interesting to see what the final conclusions will be in next year's report. However, so far it seems clear that investment consultants will need to look hard at the advice they offer to clients to ensure they can demonstrate where they have added value.

  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  
  • Topics
  • Investment
  • FCA
  • consultant
  • Aon Hewitt
  • Mercer
  • Willis Towers Watson
  • Punter Southall
  • Cardano
  • LCP

More on Investment

Five ESG questions pension trustees should be asking

Trustees are under increasing pressure to give more consideration to ESG factors. Stephanie Baxter looks at the most important questions they should be asking.

  • Investment
  • 22 February 2021
Market Movers blog: What's the latest in markets?
Market Movers Blog: Platform bosses urge Treasury to open up 'unfair' IPO market - reports

In this live blog, Professional Pensions' sister title Investment Week collates all the breaking market news, analysis and opinion on equity, bond and currency movements as well as the impact of trade wars, tightening monetary policy and the Brexit negotiations....

  • Investment
  • 22 February 2021
Industry Voice: Your questions answered by Federated Hermes impact opportunities

Your Questions Answered: a quarterly Q&A series featuring the top 10 questions that clients and prospective clients ask our investment teams.

  • Investment
  • 22 February 2021
Melley: Fiduciary management has gone from a bit of a fringe player to the main stage
Four in five believe 2020 shows need for governance review

Last year proved so significant that it merits an evaluation of governance arrangements, according to four in five respondents to a poll.

  • Investment
  • 19 February 2021
RPMI warns companies on climate reporting and workforce treatment

RPMI Railpen has updated its voting policy to focus on climate reporting, workforce treatment, and health and safety, particularly focusing on behaviour throughout the pandemic.

  • Investment
  • 18 February 2021
blog comments powered by Disqus
Back to Top

Most read

BA defers £450m of DRCs after 'swift and severe' pandemic closures
BA defers £450m of DRCs after 'swift and severe' pandemic closures
Zedra acquires Inside Pensions
Zedra acquires Inside Pensions
Deutsche Bank agrees £570m buy-in with L&G
Deutsche Bank agrees £570m buy-in with L&G
TPR flexes powers after 8,200 quarterly AE breach increase
TPR flexes powers after 8,200 quarterly AE breach increase
Investment management 'not fit for purpose' in delivering sustainable wealth creation
Investment management 'not fit for purpose' in delivering sustainable wealth creation
Trustpilot

 

  • Contact Us
  • Marketing solutions
  • About Incisive Media
  • Terms and conditions
  • Policies
  • Careers
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Newsletters
  • YouTube

© Incisive Business Media (IP) Limited, Published by Incisive Business Media Limited, New London House, 172 Drury Lane, London WC2B 5QR, registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 09177174 & 09178013

Digital publisher of the year
Digital publisher of the year 2010, 2013, 2016 & 2017
Loading