• Home
  • Admin/Tech
  • Benefits
  • Buzz
  • DB
  • DC
  • Diversity
  • Investment
  • Law & regulation
  • Risk reduction
  • Events
  • Whitepapers
  • Spotlights
  • Digital Edition
  • PPTV
  • Newsletters
  • Sign in
  •  
      • Newsletters
      • Account details
      • Contact support
      • Sign out
     
    •  

      You are currently accessing ProfessionalPensions via your Enterprise account.

      If you already have an account please use the link below to sign in.

      If you have any problems with your access or would like to request an individual access account please contact our customer service team.

      Phone: +44 (0) 1858 438800

      Email: [email protected]

      • Sign in
  • Follow us
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • Newsletters
    • YouTube
  • Register
  • Subscribe
  • Events
    • Upcoming events
      event logo
      Investment Conference

      This two part Investment Conference will bring you the latest updates from economists, asset managers and pension consultants. We will be taking a look at the outlook for the 2021 economy, alternatives, cashflow strategies and global equity markets to name a few, assessing how they fared through the volatility and what we can expect for the year ahead.

      • Date: 20 Jan 2021
      • Digital Conference
      event logo
      Webinar: Using passion for ESG to unleash member engagement

      This webinar will look at how pension schemes can harness their members’ interest in ESG to engage them more broadly with their pensions. In particular, it will look at exclusive research showing how members are reacting to ESG; their propensity to act versus their actual behaviour; and the expectations they have of providers in this regard.

      • Date: 26 Jan 2021
      • Webinar
      event logo
      Webinar: What to put on your GMP Equalisation project roadmap for 2021

      This webinar will bring together views from actuaries, lawyers, administrators, trustees and data experts to look at the pragmatic, collaborative solutions that are open to schemes to solve the GMP equalisation challenges in 2021. It will assess the individual challenges schemes face with equalisations and provide some practical options that are available to resolve these issues.

      • Date: 02 Feb 2021
      • Webinar
      event logo
      Webinar: Will the world return to normal in 2021?

      In this webinar, PP editor Jonathan Stapleton will be joined by BMO’s chief economist Steven Bell and director of fiduciary management, Christy Jesudasan, alongside PTL trustee director Melanie Cusack and Isio’s head of fiduciary management oversight Paula Champion to discuss the significant impact of these themes on the pensions sector.

      • Date: 04 Feb 2021
      • Webinar
      View all events
      Follow our Professional Pension Events

      Sign up to receive email alerts about our events

      Sign up

  • Whitepapers
    • How DC schemes can gain exposure to different asset classes in a low-return environment

      So far, DC plans have largely been focused on the onset of auto-enrolment and changes to the regulatory framework - be it the ‘charge cap,' ‘pension freedoms' or consultations around ‘value for money', says Annabel Tonry, Executive Director at J.P. Morgan Asset Management (JPMAM).

      Download
      Pension freedoms three years on

      In 2015 George Osborne, then the UK Chancellor of the Exchequer, decided that those age over 55 could take much more of their pension in cash. This has since opened up a range of possibilities for DC scheme members in the world of pensions.

      Download
      Find whitepapers
      Search by title or subject area
      View all whitepapers
  • Spotlights
  • Digital Edition
Professional Pensions
Professional Pensions
Sponsored by T. Rowe Price
  • Home
  • Admin/Tech
  • Benefits
  • Buzz
  • DB
  • DC
  • Diversity
  • Investment
  • Law & regulation
  • Risk reduction
 
    • Newsletters
    • Account details
    • Contact support
    • Sign out
 
  •  

    You are currently accessing ProfessionalPensions via your Enterprise account.

    If you already have an account please use the link below to sign in.

    If you have any problems with your access or would like to request an individual access account please contact our customer service team.

    Phone: +44 (0) 1858 438800

    Email: [email protected]

    • Sign in
  • Law and Regulation

Plumbers' pension plight needs urgent government action

Plumbers' pension plight needs urgent government action
  • Stephanie Baxter
  • Stephanie Baxter
  • 06 January 2017
  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  
0 Comments
At a glance 
  • Section 75 debt rule is still causing angst for small employers in non-associated multi-employer schemes 
  • DWP must find a solution for beleaguered plumbing firms who face financial difficulties

Section 75 debt regulation is inadvertently causing huge financial distress for employers in the industry-wide plumbers' scheme. After years of inaction the government must urgently find a solution, writes Stephanie Baxter

The plight faced by small employers in industry-wide pension schemes is a classic example of the unintended consequences of regulation. Legislation introduced years ago to increase the commitment on employers in honouring pension promises to protect members is inadvertently causing some firms major torment.

Plumbers' plight

Related articles

  • 2021 outlook: What's next for scheme governance?
  • 2021 outlook: What's next for regulation?
  • 2021 outlook: What's next for ESG?
  • 2021 outlook: What's next for schemes?

This is particularly the case for small plumbing firms in the Plumbing and Mechanical Services Industry Pension Scheme. Some could face bankruptcy because in addition to their own liabilities, they are also liable for a proportion of pension debt of past employers who have left the scheme or gone bust - called orphan liabilities.

The law requires employers to pay section 75 debt upon certain triggers, such as leaving the scheme because they have no more active employees in the scheme. It is also triggered if the employer goes out of business or the owner wants to retire. The situation is not helped by the debt being based on a buyout basis, making it more costly than under technical provisions.

It particularly affects small employers without limited liability status, as owners can be held personally liable for the firm's debts.

Federation of Small Businesses (FSB) national chairman Mike Cherry says: "We have had some FSB members affected by this, and it clearly has the potential to be financially devastating for those involved. FSB has raised this with the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) and await the department's proposals to resolve this difficult issue."

The plumbers' situation has been called a ‘scandal', a claim strongly rejected by the scheme's trustee chairman Alan Pickering.

"This isn't a scandal, as that would suggest people have behaved badly but nobody has here. We are victims of the political system, and one symptom of that is a lack of continuity and knowledge in government departments," he says.

"Nobody has done anything wrong - even political changes were well-intentioned but had unintended consequences."

There is uproar over why DWP has still not resolved the matter despite having consulted on the section 75 debt issue for non-associated multi-employer schemes back in 2015. Former pensions minister Ros Altmann says she started work on the matter in summer 2015.

Yet current pensions minister Richard Harrington told MPs last October he was looking into the matter and hoped to issue a formal consultation soon. The issue seems to be that DWP sees this as a very complex policy, and wants to take time to ensure it analyses everything properly.

A DWP spokesperson said: "This is a unique situation and we are reviewing these arrangements to explore other ways of dealing with potential debt."

Find a solution

The plumbers' scheme wants to have a lock-in with civil servants and ministers to look at the potential options, and discuss how to come up with a solution.

The difficulty is finding a solution that strikes the right balance and does not compromise member protection.

Pickering says the real challenge is not to overstate the problem, pointing out the scheme was fully funded on technical provisions in 2014. Now it is estimated to have a £1bn deficit. Yet in a few years' time if there are interest rate increases, the level of debt could be a fraction of what it is now.

"Time could be a great healer. I wouldn't want to put too much faith in future market movements but we have time, as we're reasonably well funded on an ongoing basis.

"It's just the haphazard timing associated with section 75 trigger events that really causes the angst for small family businesses who have been going the right thing by their workers since 1975 (when the scheme started)."

There are a number of family plumbing businesses where the proprietor wants to retire or pass business to someone else - which often will be a trigger event.

"If we can find a way of avoiding such a trigger or controlling the way in which it occurs, then time will be on our side," he adds.

Spence & Partners owner David Davison says the real issue is the timing of the payment of the debt, which currently creates a "cliff edge". "Giving employers the flexibility to continue to pay down benefits on a technical basis, means they can choose at what point they want to settle the cessation debt."

The threat of triggering a large debt can drive perverse behaviour among employers. Sarah Woodfield, senior policy adviser at Pensions and Lifetime Savings Association (PLSA), says this encourages employers to think how to avoid triggering the debt, such as keeping one or a few employees in the scheme and accruing benefits. This can put members and other employers in the scheme at greater risk.

The PLSA believes the best solution would be to trigger the debt when the employer's last active member departs, but calculate it on technical provisions rather than a buyout basis.

While it is a knotty issue that needs to be considered carefully, the plight of plumbing firms clearly needs urgent action. Davison says it's not a complicated issue but just needs some will to try to address it.

There have been rumours it may be addressed in the DWP's forthcoming green paper on defined benefit reform, but was unconfirmed by DWP.

"We need it quickly - in January rather than June," says Pickering. "The longer the uncertainty persists, the more employers and employees fear the worst."

  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  
  • Topics
  • Law and Regulation
  • Defined Benefit
  • plumbers
  • Pensions and Lifetime Savings Association
  • defined benefit pension plan
  • Alan Pickering
  • David Davison
  • Sarah Woodfield
  • Richard Harrington
  • Ros Altmann
  • Mike Cherry

More on Law and Regulation

DB funding - December 2020: Deficit up £76bn over 2020, says PPF

Every month, several firms issue trackers of the aggregate defined benefit (DB) scheme funding position. See here for the December 2020 estimates on the various measures…

  • Defined Benefit
  • 12 January 2021
Palmer: Evaluating and monitoring sponsor longevity cannot be undertaken formulaically
ECPA issues warning over changes to sponsor longevity assumptions

Schemes need to dynamically and closely monitor the position of their employer covenant and its corporate longevity, ensuring the assessment is not conducted in isolation, the Employer Covenant Practitioners Association (ECPA) says.

  • Defined Benefit
  • 11 January 2021
Hymans Robertson and Isio appointed to Scottish Enterprise Scheme

The Scottish Enterprise Pension & Life Assurance Scheme (SEPLAS) has appointed Hymans Robertson and Isio following a formal tender process.

  • Defined Benefit
  • 06 January 2021
2021 outlook: What's next for regulation?

After a year that took everyone by surprise, experts tell Professional Pensions what could be on the horizon for regulation in 2021.

  • Law and Regulation
  • 30 December 2020
Managing operational and costs considerations is key to overall success

Marian Elliott looks at the key factors for reaching schemes’ set goals.

  • Defined Benefit
  • 29 December 2020
blog comments powered by Disqus
Back to Top

Most read

Opperman: New TPR powers will not be backdated
Opperman: New TPR powers will not be backdated
Barclays Bank UK Retirement Fund integrates ESG and climate risk into £1.3bn DGF
Barclays Bank UK Retirement Fund integrates ESG and climate risk into £1.3bn DGF
Hymans Robertson and Isio appointed to Scottish Enterprise Scheme
Hymans Robertson and Isio appointed to Scottish Enterprise Scheme
DWP urged to give pension funds a stronger steer on dashboard data
DWP urged to give pension funds a stronger steer on dashboard data
Overloaded fraud police need industry support on scams, MPs told
Overloaded fraud police need industry support on scams, MPs told
Trustpilot

 

  • Contact Us
  • Marketing solutions
  • About Incisive Media
  • Terms and conditions
  • Policies
  • Careers
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Newsletters
  • YouTube

© Incisive Business Media (IP) Limited, Published by Incisive Business Media Limited, New London House, 172 Drury Lane, London WC2B 5QR, registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 09177174 & 09178013

Digital publisher of the year
Digital publisher of the year 2010, 2013, 2016 & 2017
Loading