Is gamification the way forward for pensions?

An ugly word for an attractive idea


Keir Macdonald looks at how gamification can change the pensions industry.

At a glance
  • Gamification techniques have been used to encourage customer loyalty. 
  • Such techniques can make complex material more engaging. 
  • We need to get young peoples’ perspective on saving if we are to engage them with pensions.

If you haven't yet heard of ‘gamification' don't worry: you are not alone. But it might just be something that is about to enter the lexicon of UK pensions jargon. Gamification is essentially the application of typical elements of game playing and technology to other spheres of life.

"Gamification" was coined by British programmer Nick Pelling and has been embraced by cutting-edge US tech firms to motivate employees and encourage customer loyalty via social media. It is also making waves in the US pensions world and in the 401(k) arena, where the application of game-like techniques are motivating employees to save more.

At RedSTART, a financial education initiative for young people, we are already seeing gamification in action. When running sessions with younger students, the day is focused around setting challenges in which the pupils make investments in different areas, trying to be the one to make the most money by the end of the day. As the day progresses we explain how risk, reward, and compound interest are at work within the challenges. Those who take the most advantage of these factors are those who will have saved most by the end of the day.

Retirement saving needs to be ‘Easy, Attractive, Social and Timely'. At the moment, it is not.

To see the future of gamification in savings, the best place to look is at more tech-savvy young people. We have already seen it in our recent "Classroom to Boardroom" session in conjunction with charity - Entrepeneurs in Action - an initiative that aims to inspire young people to be more entrepreneurial and employable.

A group of students were set the task of creating an idea for how to engage more young people with savings. The pupils came up with a compelling business case to develop a smartphone app that would encourage saving through educational games and social media. Fronted by a "Pensions Panda", they proposed that saving could be rewarded with "Nectar-style" points which could be redeemed over time for things such as concert tickets, discounts in stores, or donations to charity.

Increase engagement
Gamification, like this, is one of the most effective ways to make otherwise complex material interactive and engaging. One only has to look at how it has taken off in other areas of life to see its effect. One of the best examples is personal fitness where FitBits, Jawbones and many other personal activity monitoring devices offer individuals the chance to see how many steps they've walked, how far they've cycled, how many calories they've burned on a daily basis.

It becomes an almost an irresistible challenge to try to walk just that one step further than the day before. It also underlines a fundamental principle - setting goals and realistic incremental objectives can help one achieve previously thought unsurmountable challenges. This applies to something simple like depositing in to a bank account to complex savings vehicles, such as a DC schemes.

The recent Age of Responsibility report, produced by Redington in conjunction with Lord Hutton found that retirement saving falls too far down people's priorities list. In the age of defined contribution pensions, where the onus is on the individual to save for their own retirement, this is a disaster waiting to happen.

The Age of Responsibility paper sums up the main problems in four words: retirement saving needs to be ‘Easy, Attractive, Social and Timely'. At the moment, it is not. People need now, more than ever, to see how their pension plan is working: with their current investments - how much money will they have each year when they retire? How does that compare with what they earn now? How will changing their investments alter this? Will buying an annuity make them better off?

As soon as people are able to visualise this, see their investments in action, projected into the future, and interact with them easily, then engagement with retirement savings will become much simpler, and will show people just what they have to do now to ensure that they have comfortable in the future. Visualisation ‘or gamification' may be central to this.

To envisage the future of saving and investing we need to go back to the classroom. We need to listen to young people and get their perspective. How will they best engage and understand something that they have no experience of? If they're not engaging with it, then it's not being done correctly. And if it's not being done correctly, it must be changed.

Keir Macdonald is an analyst at Redington



More on Communication

No consensus on timing of pension choices comms

No consensus on timing of pension choices comms

The industry has differing views on when choices should be communicated to members

Holly Roach
clock 01 August 2022 • 2 min read
'Carrot and stick' approach to engagement is redundant

'Carrot and stick' approach to engagement is redundant

Cushon says schemes cannot hide behind old methods of member communication

Hope William-Smith
clock 15 March 2022 • 1 min read
Martin Lewis: The face that launched 13 million emails

What did someone with 13 million subscribers tell the pensions industry about engagement?

Martin Lewis founded Money Saving Expert, a website that has since built up an email following of 13 million people, after investing just £100 in a website at the beginning of the millennium. But how has Lewis achieved such cracking engagement? And what...

Jonathan Stapleton
clock 13 October 2020 • 4 min read