• Home
  • Admin/Tech
  • Benefits
  • Buzz
  • DB
  • DC
  • Diversity
  • Investment
  • Law & regulation
  • Risk reduction
  • Events
  • Whitepapers
  • Spotlights
  • Digital Edition
  • PPTV
  • Newsletters
  • Sign in
  •  
      • Newsletters
      • Account details
      • Contact support
      • Sign out
     
    •  

      You are currently accessing ProfessionalPensions via your Enterprise account.

      If you already have an account please use the link below to sign in.

      If you have any problems with your access or would like to request an individual access account please contact our customer service team.

      Phone: +44 (0) 1858 438800

      Email: [email protected]

      • Sign in
  • Follow us
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • Newsletters
    • YouTube
  • Register
  • Subscribe
  • Events
    • Upcoming events
      event logo
      WSB Webinar: Tackling financial wellbeing in the workplace

      This webinar will explore how employers can help employees take control of their finances through the provision of financial education and guidance. It will look at how such financial education programmes should be delivered to ensure maximum engagement as well as the content such offerings should include.

      • Date: 23 Feb 2021
      • Webinar
      event logo
      Webinar - LGIM Climate Solutions: how we measure climate risk and alignment in investors’ portfolios

      As investors move to incorporate a greater focus on climate change into their portfolios, there is an increasing requirement to be able to quantify and report on the climate credentials of investments and to what extent they are aligned with the goals of the Paris Agreement.In this webinar, LGIM explain how they quantify portfolio alignment with the Paris goals, using a combination of historical and forward-looking measures.

      • Date: 24 Feb 2021
      • Webinar
      event logo
      Admin & Data Forum 2021

      This concise half-day event will explore a variety of different issues affecting scheme managers, through a combination of informative presentations and interactive panel debates, including GMP equalisation, the pensions dashboard, the accuracy and quality of members data and the latest trends in scheme administration.

      • Date: 04 Mar 2021
      event logo
      Defined Benefit Consolidation Conference

      Professional Pensions is hosting this concise digital event on the 25th March to provide a crucial update on where the current regulation stands on DB Consolidators, assess the different models available, what the expected funding levels are and the governance requirements. This event will be a combination of short presentations followed by live Q&A’s with our expert speakers allowing plenty of time to answer your questions.

      • Date: 25 Mar 2021
      • Digital Conference
      View all events
      Follow our Professional Pension Events

      Sign up to receive email alerts about our events

      Sign up

  • Whitepapers
    • How DC schemes can gain exposure to different asset classes in a low-return environment

      So far, DC plans have largely been focused on the onset of auto-enrolment and changes to the regulatory framework - be it the ‘charge cap,' ‘pension freedoms' or consultations around ‘value for money', says Annabel Tonry, Executive Director at J.P. Morgan Asset Management (JPMAM).

      Download
      Pension freedoms three years on

      In 2015 George Osborne, then the UK Chancellor of the Exchequer, decided that those age over 55 could take much more of their pension in cash. This has since opened up a range of possibilities for DC scheme members in the world of pensions.

      Download
      Find whitepapers
      Search by title or subject area
      View all whitepapers
  • Spotlights
  • Digital Edition
Professional Pensions
Professional Pensions
  • Home
  • Admin/Tech
  • Benefits
  • Buzz
  • DB
  • DC
  • Diversity
  • Investment
  • Law & regulation
  • Risk reduction
 
    • Newsletters
    • Account details
    • Contact support
    • Sign out
 
  •  

    You are currently accessing ProfessionalPensions via your Enterprise account.

    If you already have an account please use the link below to sign in.

    If you have any problems with your access or would like to request an individual access account please contact our customer service team.

    Phone: +44 (0) 1858 438800

    Email: [email protected]

    • Sign in
  • Employee Benefits

Going for gold: What makes a top quality DC scheme?

Going for gold: What makes a top quality DC scheme?
  • Jonathan Stapleton
  • Jonathan Stapleton
  • @jonstapleton
  • 25 October 2016
  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  
0 Comments

The corporate pensions market has changed radically over the past five years. Jonathan Stapleton asks a range of industry experts what now makes a gold standard offering to employees.

At a Glance
  • Auto-enrolment and freedom of choice have forced employers to make changes to pension schemes
  • Contributions, governance and communication are all key in achieving a gold standard plan
  • But there also a range of other factors employers should consider


There has been huge change in pensions over the past four years following the implementation of auto-enrolment in 2012, the introduction of the pension freedoms last year and a raft of other regulatory change.

These changes have forced employers to make significant changes to their pensions offering to ensure it remains fit for purpose in a freedom and choice world. But what makes for a gold standard defined contribution (DC) pension offering today? How can employers know they are offering the best possible scheme to their staff?

Related articles

  • Five ESG questions pension trustees should be asking
  • How would a higher minimum pension age change retirement planning?
  • The challenge of GMP equalisation continues
  • 2021: The year of dashboard progress?

The Pensions Regulator's DC Code - the latest version of which was released this summer - sets out the key standards it expects trust-based schemes to achieve.

And the Pensions and Lifetime Savings Association's Pension Quality Mark - which requires schemes to demonstrate quality across three key areas: contributions, governance and communication - is also useful in determining whether a scheme is of sufficient quality.

But what does all this really mean in practice? And is it really as straightforward as completing a tick box list from the regulator or achieving an external accreditation?

PP decided to ask a number of leading providers, investment managers and consultants for their views about what makes a gold standard scheme. This is what they said.

Stephen Bowles, head of defined contribution at Schroders

A gold standard DC scheme should deliver value for money for the members but also for the sponsoring employer.

For most employers, providing a quality pension scheme will entail significant cost - both in terms of contributions and running costs. Having spent this money, the last thing the employer should accept is a sub-optimal investment strategy that limits the value of the contributions being paid - both in terms of investment returns or member perception.

Members should have a glide path which allows them to access sufficient growth in the early years (to build their pot) but that moves them into risk managed strategies (not bonds and cash) in the later years.

The end point of the glide path should also provide members with the flexibility to use their DC pot according to their circumstances when they actually retire. Assumptions shouldn't be made about what members will do at retirement.

Alistair Byrne, senior DC investment strategist at State Street Global Advisors

A gold standard pension scheme is one that reliably delivers good outcomes for members.

High levels of governance are key in achieving that, and governance quality is more determined by the effort and engagement of the parties involved than choice of legal format, be it trust, contract or master trust.

Good governance will help to ensure the scheme provides value for money for members. Engagement and education of members are worthwhile activities, but well-chosen defaults are more important.

We have seen the power of automatic enrolment in raising participation rates and behavioural insights can be effective in other areas such as automatic escalation of contributions to raise savings rates. High-quality default investment strategies are more important than encouraging members to make their own investment choices.

Catherine Doyle, UK head of DC pensions at Newton Investment Management

Defining a single gold standard in DC is not straightforward in an environment where schemes are coming from different starting points in terms of legacy arrangements, structure, size and levels of governance.

There are however basic attributes indicating excellence - the DC scheme should be given prominence by the employer, reflected in attractive contribution rates with an incentive for members to top up their contributions.

Administration should be seamless using robust and state-of-the-art technology while communications should be targeted and accessible. In addition, the default fund should be well-designed, transparent and represent value for money with a consideration of environmental, social and governance aspects embedded as an integral part of the investment process. There should also be some choice available through self-select options.

But the most prominent single feature would be the existence of a clear, member-centric objective at the scheme level, supported by sound governance, implemented by committee members with diverse experience and expertise.

David Hutchins, lead portfolio manager for EMEA multi-asset solutions at AB

We believe today's minimum pensions standard need to have the best outcome for members, net of fees, at the heart of everything they do. This can only be achieved with clear and full transparency, not only around the objectives, but also the charges and delivered performance.

Schemes require strong governance bodies which review the investment decisions and holds to account those making these on behalf of members.

The investment strategy should allow for flexibility around retirement age and use of pensions funds, as members often simply don't know nor want to be forced to make binding decision many years ahead of time.

The gold standard of schemes would take this governance even further, providing an integrated, well governed, default journey from accumulation to decumulation. These schemes would also constantly monitor the investment.

Laura Myers, partner and head of DC investment at LCP

The key driver of a gold standard DC scheme is the contribution structure because that is the main determinant in members' achieving good retirement outcomes, which will enable members to actually afford retirement.

For many companies, increasing contribution rates, beyond the requirements of auto-enrolment and expected impact of the National Living Wage, is not feasible.

However, design features like Save More Tomorrow programmes, where members are encouraged to increase contributions when they receive a pay rise, can make schemes much more effective in increasing saving levels. In addition, making your scheme a wider savings arrangement, for example alongside ISAs or LISAs, is likely to increase engagement.

Once this strong foundation is in place gold standard means ensuring the value of contributions the company, and employees, have put into the scheme is maximised. This is achieved by strong governance frameworks, robust investment strategies and communications tailored and relevant to members' circumstances.

Hugh Nolan, president of the Society of Pension Professionals

The level of contributions is still the key to how much pension members get from DC schemes. Employers in some sectors may well pay lower contributions though, focusing on other forms of remuneration. Either way, a good DC scheme will typically have some contribution matching so members are encouraged to engage and pay extra to get more from the employer too.

The savings from low charges build up significantly, and a big master trust can provide economies of scale, good governance and clever investment thinking.

In addition, investment options should be simple and the default option should be robust - typically be slightly risk averse while still seeking good returns. Finally, plain English communications and internet access will boost engagement.

The best schemes will also be reviewed periodically to keep them excellent.

Mark Pemberthy, director of JLT Employee Benefits

A gold standard DC pension scheme is one that provides the right foundations so members find it easy to make appropriate decisions and achieve good outcomes.

This includes clear communication through a variety of media giving proactive nudges at key events and milestones; a linked ISA/LISA to encourage a holistic approach to saving; adequate contribution rates; and convenient access to appropriate products and services to meet capital and income needs."

A gold standard pension scheme in today's DC world comprises:

  • A scheme structure (either trust- or contract-based) which allows strategic changes to the scheme design without requiring member consent
  • An effective governance framework with ability to make interventions to deliver desired outcomes
  • Adequate contribution rates to achieve sustainable retirement and meet other financial goals
  • An investment strategy aiming to deliver long term real returns while providing volatility management at times of capital withdrawal and income generation
  • Convenient access to appropriate products/services to meet capital and income needs
  • A linked ISA/LISA with mirror terms and governance to encourage a holistic approach to saving for wider financial objectives and as a top-up vehicle for high earners
  • Clear communication utilising a variety of media
  • Proactive nudges and messaging at key events and milestones
  • Clear guidance at key stages focused on calls to action and decision points, with access to advice when needed
  • Stable legislation to support long-term financial decisions

Darren Philp, director of policy and market engagement at The People's Pension

This summer saw a gold medal rush at the Olympics and Paralympics in Rio. I think DC pensions could learn a lot from Team GB because, while there is a load of scientific stuff going on in the background, and a lot of hard work, the basics are simple. Athletes need to run fast, jump high and shoot straight to succeed, and that's also true for DC schemes. Except the goal is excellence for members.

To run fast in DC means to recognise the changing needs of savers and constantly evolve to better meet them. Jumping high means exceeding their expectations and striving to provide strong governance. Finally, DC schemes need to shoot straight - communicating without jargon and providing simple, low-cost products and services which meet member needs. That's how DC schemes can achieve gold medal status.

Henry Tapper, director at First Actuarial and founder of the Pension Playpen

Most quality standards on this subject - in particular the PLSA's PQM - make the chief criteria for a good DC pension plan, the contribution levels of members and employers.

This has caused the PQM to become a badge for a club of well-heeled employers who can afford a reward strategy whether 10%+ of salary goes into a pension. Nice if you are in that position but not much good if you are one of 95% of employers who are not and may never be in that position.

So, in my view, a gold standard DC plan is one that delivers its promise and converts regular contributions into a string of regular payments and does this efficiently.

Efficiency means no friction (so a plan with low charges, easy contributions and prompt payments in decumulation). Gold star also means value, so a plan that delivers market-beating performance, smoothed investment returns in drawdown and convenient interfaces for both employers and members.

Importantly, a gold standard plan should not be defined in terms of employer or member contributions - and the plan should encourage sustained contributions by delivering efficiency and value.

Lynda Whitney, partner at Aon Hewitt

Aon's research shows that DC savers are typically saving £1,400 too little each year to maintain their standard of living in retirement. Our research also shows that employers are absolutely central to pension savings - members trust their employer to tell them where to save and how much to save. So a gold standard scheme would do it for them by providing:

  • Adequate default contribution rates with auto-escalation of contributions where entry rates are set at a lower level
  • A good quality default investment strategy that meets the specific needs of the membership
  • Default retirement options such as a preferred drawdown provider or in-scheme drawdown option

Where members need to make decisions the communication should be tailored and clear, with actions easy to take. Members need to see their whole finances and their future self in their decisions.

 

The Pension Quality Mark

The Pension Quality Mark (PQM) is a standard that recognises high quality defined contribution (DC) pension schemes.

It was launched by the Pensions and Lifetime Savings Association, the body then known as the National Association of Pension Funds, in September 2009 in a bid to raise confidence in workplace pensions and help employers demonstrate the value and quality of their scheme to current and future employees.

To attain PQM accreditation, schemes are independently verified to check they have excellent quality contributions, governance and communications – and can be awarded either a PQM standard or a PQM Plus standard if contribution rates are higher. The three main areas of the PQM standards are:

 

  • Contributions: PQM schemes must offer a total contribution of 10% of pay, with at least 6% from the employer. PQM Plus schemes must provide a total contribution of 15%, with at least 10% from the employer. In addition, schemes must also satisfy rules on pensionable earnings, contribution configurations and waiting periods/nursery arrangements.
  • Governance: To meet the PQM standard, employers must have adequate governance arrangements in place and make sure the pension scheme is well run and meets the needs of scheme members. Schemes also need to meet a governance structure standard and also ensure they meet standards relating to both default investment strategies and charges
  • Communication: To meet the communication standards, schemes must provide employees with initial, on-going and at-retirement communications that are clear and engaging so as to enable members to take decisions about their pension and retirement.

 


PQM Ready

PQM has also launched a standard for multi-employer master trusts called ‘PQM Ready’.

To qualify for PQM Ready, a master trust scheme needs to meet governance and communication standards.

The trustees must be fully independent – and need to be able to make, break or vary any agreement with the scheme’s fund managers and administrators; and have no commercial interest in the master trust.

The scheme also needs to have clear and engaging communications to members when joining the scheme, leaving and at retirement.

If an employer chooses a PQM Ready scheme, they can qualify for the classic PQM by meeting the contributions standard above.

 

  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  
  • Topics
  • Employee Benefits
  • Defined Contribution
  • Stephen Bowles
  • Schroders
  • SSgA
  • State Street Global Advisors
  • Alistair Byrne
  • Catherine Doyle
  • Newton Investment Management
  • AB
  • David Hutchins
  • LCP
  • Laura Myers
  • Hugh Nolan
  • SPP
  • Society of Pensions Professionals
  • JLT Employee Benefits
  • Henry Tapper
  • Darren Philp
  • The People's Pension
  • First Actuarial
  • Mark Pemberthy
  • Lynda Whitney
  • Aon Hewitt
  • HR

More on Employee Benefits

Myers: The language of regulators is not the same as the language of scheme members
LCP calls for 'fundamental rethink' on DC chair's statements

Defined contribution (DC) chair’s statements need a major re-think as part of the Department for Work and Pensions’ five-yearly statutory review on the rules around scheme governance in 2021, LCP says.

  • Defined Contribution
  • 19 February 2021
A five-point process is designed to help schemes get ready
Consolidating DC schemes urged to act before 'capacity crunch'

Trustees must undertake a five-step process urgently if they are seeking to move their single-employer defined contribution (DC) scheme into a master trust, says Premier.

  • Defined Contribution
  • 17 February 2021
Workplace savings fintech Cushon has expanded its acquisition target to include pension-focused businesses as well as master trusts.
Cushon eyes more master trusts after Salvus acquisition

Workplace savings fintech Cushon has expanded its acquisition target to include pension-focused businesses as well as master trusts.

  • Defined Contribution
  • 11 February 2021
Nest said members have been able to continue saving in the same way
AE remains resilient despite pandemic and pension contribution increases

Auto-enrolment (AE) remained resilient during the Covid-19 pandemic and in the wake of minimum contribution increases, according to a report by Nest Insight.

  • Defined Contribution
  • 10 February 2021
Ball: Projects are becoming increasingly more sophisticated
Quarter of schemes switch to DC master trusts; a further half planning similar move

Transfers to defined contribution (DC) master trusts will continue well into 2021, latest research from Sackers reveals.

  • Defined Contribution
  • 10 February 2021
blog comments powered by Disqus
Back to Top

Most read

BA defers £450m of DRCs after 'swift and severe' pandemic closures
BA defers £450m of DRCs after 'swift and severe' pandemic closures
Zedra acquires Inside Pensions
Zedra acquires Inside Pensions
Deutsche Bank agrees £570m buy-in with L&G
Deutsche Bank agrees £570m buy-in with L&G
TPR flexes powers after 8,200 quarterly AE breach increase
TPR flexes powers after 8,200 quarterly AE breach increase
Industry Voice: Your questions answered by Federated Hermes impact opportunities
Industry Voice: Your questions answered by Federated Hermes impact opportunities
Trustpilot

 

  • Contact Us
  • Marketing solutions
  • About Incisive Media
  • Terms and conditions
  • Policies
  • Careers
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Newsletters
  • YouTube

© Incisive Business Media (IP) Limited, Published by Incisive Business Media Limited, New London House, 172 Drury Lane, London WC2B 5QR, registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 09177174 & 09178013

Digital publisher of the year
Digital publisher of the year 2010, 2013, 2016 & 2017
Loading