Governance Watch - November 2020: The rise of shareholder dissent
Manifest-Minerva's Thomas Bolger takes a look at key issues at upcoming AGMs, focusing this month on the rise of shareholder dissent.
The 2020 annual general meeting (AGM) season has taken place in unprecedented times, with the coronavirus pandemic causing severe economic and social costs globally. The world and business landscape have changed, and as a result, boards and investors are facing new and challenging decisions.
Within this context, Minerva Analytics' 2020 UK Voting Review found that the average overall dissent across all resolutions considered at shareholder meetings of the UK's largest 350 companies was 3.13% in 2020 (January to August). This is above both the 2.93% level for the whole of 2019 and currently stands at its highest level in seven years.
The chart above shows the number of companies and the number of resolutions that received 20% or more dissent since 2014 - when shareholders were given a binding vote on remuneration policy. It shows that a greater number of resolutions have received high dissent in 2020 compared to 2019. The data also suggests dissent has been more concentrated, indicating that shareholders are "picking their battles", which has resulted in a smaller number of companies receiving high dissent but a larger number of resolutions with high dissent.
Of the 63 companies receiving high dissent on at least one resolution this year, 46% were repeat offenders, i.e. the company also received high dissent in 2019. This would seem to suggest a breakdown in communication: either companies are not listening to feedback, or shareholders are not explaining effectively - or possibly a mixture of both. It does not help either shareholders or boards when most companies have a 31 December year end and hold their AGMs within a narrow sixweek window. The engagement process this year will have also been impacted by the coronavirus pandemic.
The number of defeated management-proposed resolutions and successful shareholder proposals have also increased. In 2020, 21 resolutions have been voted down by shareholders compared to five in the whole of 2019, and 12 shareholder proposals have been successful compared to only one in 2019. This increase has been impacted by the ongoing shareholder fight over the future direction of Petropavlovsk plc and the composition of its board. All 12 successful shareholder proposals and nine of the defeated managementproposed resolutions occurred at Petropavlovsk.
The report found that shareholder dissent has increased this year. This could be expected given the increased scrutiny boards find themselves under during this time of crisis and the evolving public expectations on the roles and responsibilities of businesses.
Governance practices and, in particular, executive remuneration and the treatment of stakeholders are under even closer scrutiny from shareholders, employees, regulators and governments.
Thomas Bolger is stewardship team leader at Manifest-Minerva
Annual General Meetings in November
|
Company |
FTSE Index | Event Date | Event Type | Proxy Deadline |
| Genesis Emerging Markets Fund | FTSE 250 | 2 Nov 20 | AGM | 29 Oct 20 |
| Manchester & London Investment Trust | FTSE SmallCap | 2 Nov 20 | AGM | 31 Oct 20 |
| GCP Student Living | FTSE 250 | 4 Nov 20 | AGM | 2 Nov 20 |
| Hansard Global | FTSE Fledgling | 4 Nov 20 | AGM | 2 Nov 20 |
| JPMorgan Global Growth & Income | FTSE SmallCap | 4 Nov 20 | AGM | 2 Nov 20 |
| Wilmington | FTSE Fledgling | 4 Nov 20 | AGM | 2 Nov 20 |
| JPMorgan Emerging Markets Investment Trust | FTSE 250 | 5 Nov 20 | AGM | 3 Nov 20 |
| Redrow | FTSE 250 | 6 Nov 20 | AGM | 4 Nov 20 |
| Pacific Horizon Investment Trust | FTSE SmallCap | 10 Nov 20 | AGM | 6 Nov 20 |
| Hays | FTSE 250 | 11 Nov 20 | AGM | 9 Nov 20 |
| Rank Group | FTSE 250 | 11 Nov 20 | AGM | 9 Nov 20 |
| James Halstead | AIM | 12 Nov 20 | AGM | 10 Nov 20 |
| Ricardo | FTSE SmallCap | 12 Nov 20 | AGM | 10 Nov 20 |
| DFS Furniture | FTSE SmallCap | 13 Nov 20 | AGM | 11 Nov 20 |
| Galliford Try | FTSE SmallCap | 13 Nov 20 | AGM | 11 Nov 20 |
| European Opportunities Trust | FTSE 250 | 16 Nov 20 | AGM | 12 Nov 20 |
| Smiths Group | FTSE 100 | 16 Nov 20 | AGM | 14 Nov 20 |
| BMO Real Estate Investments | FTSE SmallCap | 17 Nov 20 | AGM | 13 Nov 20 |
| Craneware | AIM | 17 Nov 20 | AGM | Not Yet Disclosed/Collected |
| Dunelm Group | FTSE 250 | 17 Nov 20 | AGM | 13 Nov 20 |
| Avingtrans | AIM | 18 Nov 20 | AGM | 16 Nov 20 |
| Henderson EuroTrust | FTSE SmallCap | 18 Nov 20 | AGM | 16 Nov 20 |
| Picton Property Income | FTSE SmallCap | 18 Nov 20 | AGM | 16 Nov 20 |
| Close Brothers Group | FTSE 250 | 19 Nov 20 | AGM | 17 Nov 20 |
| Finsbury Food Group | AIM | 19 Nov 20 | AGM | Not Yet Disclosed/Collected |
| McBride | FTSE SmallCap | 23 Nov 20 | AGM | Not Yet Disclosed/Collected |
| Go-Ahead Group | FTSE SmallCap | 24 Nov 20 | AGM | 20 Nov 20 |
| JPMorgan Smaller Companies Investment Trust | FTSE SmallCap | 24 Nov 20 | AGM | 20 Nov 20 |
| Genus | FTSE 250 | 25 Nov 20 | AGM | 23 Nov 20 |
| Clinigen Group | AIM | 26 Nov 20 | AGM | 24 Nov 20 |
| CVS Group | AIM | 26 Nov 20 | AGM | Not Yet Disclosed/Collected |
| DX (Group) | AIM | 26 Nov 20 | AGM | Not Yet Disclosed/Collected |
| Hotel Chocolat Group | AIM | 27 Nov 20 | AGM | 25 Nov 20 |
| Murray Income Trust | FTSE SmallCap | 27 Nov 20 | AGM | 25 Nov 20 |
| Macau Property Opportunities Fund | FTSE Fledgling | 30 Nov 20 | AGM | Not Yet Disclosed/Collected |
Source: Manifest-Minerva
More on Investment
CACEIS launches carbon metrics tool for all UK schemes
CACEIS has launched a carbon metrics reporting tool specifically designed to help UK pension schemes meet their upcoming disclosure obligations.
BlackRock launches private debt fund for pension schemes
BlackRock has launched a private debt fund specifically designed for UK pension schemes to access a variety of global private debt market exposures via a single strategy.
Realism vs ambition: Setting pension scheme net-zero targets
The Environment Agency Pension Fund's Marion Maloney joins with Aon's Tim Manuel and ITS's Tegs Harding to discuss net-zero targets and what sits behind them
How schemes are investing to make a real-world impact
Real-world impact is increasingly being filtered into schemes’ investment decisions and mindset, writes Stephanie Baxter
Pension scheme inflation hedging activity falls in Q1
Pension scheme inflation hedging activity fell by 17% quarter-on-quarter to £30.4bn in the first three months of the year, BMO Global Asset Management research reveals.
