Companies urged to take control of DB valuations

Trustees rather than sponsor leading valuation in 61% of cases say schemes

clock • 1 min read
Alistair Russell-Smith - sponsors can achieve better corporate outcomes and manage increased regulatory risk
Image:

Alistair Russell-Smith - sponsors can achieve better corporate outcomes and manage increased regulatory risk

Companies should take more control of valuation processes for their defined benefit (DB) schemes to help manage the regulatory risk they face, according to Hymans Robertson.

The consultancy has found nearly two thirds (61%) of pension scheme professionals reported valuation being overseen by trustees instead of the companies.

Hymans Robertson head of corporate DB Alistair Russell-Smith said oversight must shift to companies due to the greater regulatory pressure now aimed at sponsors - urging companies to plan valuations like they would a corporate transaction.

He says: "By considering the options upfront and taking a proposal to the trustees, rather than waiting for the trustees to act, they can achieve better corporate outcomes and manage increased regulatory risk."

Factors to consider include key actuarial assumptions such as RPI, the CPI wedge and longevity, as well as whether or not to introduce an inflation risk premium to reduce the inflation assumption, particularly when inflation risk is not hedged

He said there is arguably also now sufficient evidence to make some allowance for Covid-19 in the longevity assumptions - adding it was also worth considering funding expenses out of scheme assets if the scheme is in a technical provisions surplus.

Russell-Smith added: "There's a useful conversation to be had with pension scheme trustees around balancing investment risk and covenant risk - is it better to keep on investment risk and buy-out sooner or keep de-risking and take longer to buy-out? 

"It's worth remembering, too, that newly emerging end game solutions such as superfunds and capital backed journey plans should also be assessed when developing a corporate DB end game strategy."

Jon Yarker is a financial journalist at Rhotic Media

More on Defined Benefit

Aggregate DB surplus rises by £7.3bn in July

Aggregate DB surplus rises by £7.3bn in July

PPF says funding ratio at highest level since July 2023, as liabilities drop faster than assets

Alex Levy
clock 11 August 2026 • 2 min read
Historical analysis key to DB surplus allocation, says Hymans

Historical analysis key to DB surplus allocation, says Hymans

Analysis of past contribution split can provide an objective basis for negotiations

Alex Levy
clock 06 August 2026 • 3 min read
Schemes urged to stop treating buyout as automatic default

Schemes urged to stop treating buyout as automatic default

SPP report suggests schemes should take ‘objective-led’ approach to endgame planning

Holly Roach
clock 06 August 2026 • 1 min read
Trustpilot