Rachel Harris: By focussing on narrowing the range to try and improve or remove poorer-performing schemes, the framework risks dragging higher-performing schemes towards the median.
Regulatory efforts to ensure defined contribution (DC) pension schemes deliver genuine long-term value for members are both welcome and necessary. This is why the ambition behind the value for money (VfM) framework deserves the industry’s ongoing support.
However, it is important for policy always to keep pace with the market. While the framework has undoubtedly improved through consultation and engagement, the DC landscape is continually evolving, meaning authorities risk aiming at a moving target.
Participants from across the DC ecosystem are increasingly raising concerns that this complex annual exercise will place significant data, reporting, and governance burdens on schemes of all types.
And following the publication of the draft regulations and Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) rules, it is worth stepping back and asking whether it still delivers against its objectives at a reasonable cost, given the changing shape of the market.
An evolving market
For master trusts (even although they are large and growing and therefore could have the resourcing to undertake an annual VfM test) this will nonetheless be an enormous undertaking while these entities grapple with the consequences of the Pension Schemes Act.
This act is rapidly consolidating the commercial sector. By 2030, this segment will comprise a small number of very large schemes. This creates a market where the Pensions Regulator and the FCA can provide close, proactive supervision of how member funds are invested and challenge providers on value for money, with or without the detailed framework proposed in the consultation.
For single-employer trusts, the framework will be a substantial new responsibility that will likely fall to the advisors, with members bearing the cost, directly or indirectly. For many schemes, this may expedite plans to outsource to a master trust.
Meanwhile, the Mansion House reforms are sharpening the focus on long-term value and the role of private assets. Asset allocations are already evolving, and for some single-employer schemes, this has created another reason to outsource to larger pools where scale helps schemes access private markets more effectively. These rapidly changing DC market dynamics highlight the importance of proportionality and require a creative approach to applying the structure.
This means softening the requirement for all schemes to carry out the full exercise every year, particularly as most members hold long-term asset allocations. While the proposed exemption for trust-based arrangements that have agreed to outsource to a master trust is welcome, it could be broadened to lessen the overall burden.
A proportionate approach
While further industry-wide consultation is prudent, we have identified some select enhancements to the framework. First, all single-employer trusts could be required to carry out a full assessment once, before a one- to two-year pause to allow the market to take stock and trustees to decide on individual schemes.
In addition, with DC schemes already required to review asset allocation once every three years, those with a ‘light green' or ‘dark green' assessment under the new framework could move to a triennial exercise to align with the existing requirement.
On the commercial side, questions remain about the framework's automatic sanctions. An abrupt closure to new business and communication of an ‘amber' rating would be hugely disruptive, particularly given how concentrated the segment will be.
Close, proactive supervision around the framework, without automatic sanctions, is likely a better way to approach this part of the market. There is a case for delaying the framework's application to commercial providers until after the 2030 deadlines for the scale test and the Mansion House Accord have passed.
Raising the standards
As the Investment Association has flagged, the framework intentionally seeks to reduce the dispersion of outcomes in the market, at worst, a ‘race to the middle'. But do we want middling outcomes for pension savers?
The focus should absolutely be on raising the performance of ‘stragglers' at the lower end of the market, but for everyone else, the aim should be to increase performance gradually – a ‘march to the top'. By focussing on narrowing the range to try and improve or remove poorer-performing schemes, the framework risks dragging higher-performing schemes towards the median.
While these risks are inherent in any benchmarking exercise, the effects could be lessened. For example, in the growth phase, broad asset allocation-based comparisons make sense, as schemes share a similar goal of maximising growth within sensible risk limits.
However, as members move closer to retirement, intended outcomes can diverge materially between schemes with different demographics, and between members within schemes with different decumulation strategies. Therefore, it makes more sense to measure schemes against their own stated targets and not any scheme-to-scheme comparison.
Implementing the VfM framework is a positive step forward for DC pensions. But as the realities of the framework have become clearer, it is prudent for the authorities to pause and reflect on the changing dynamics of the market and find ways to ensure it achieves the desired outcomes – without burdening the sector, and ultimately members, unnecessarily.
Rachel Harris is head of UK institutional at Schroders



