Industry Voice: Back to reality part III - Fiduciary risk

Kim Crabtree looks at the important role of active management in defined contribution schemes

clock • 2 min read

In this series, we address and challenge common misconceptions that have led to the increased prevalence of passive investments in defined contribution (DC) schemes.

To help trustees and corporate advisers weigh the pros and cons of active management, we perform a reality check on each misconception, referencing fiduciary principles and market and member survey data.

This installment addresses the misconception that passive investment options reduce fiduciary risk, defined as the risk that the scheme services and funds do not achieve value for money.1

There is no denying that passive investments offer market returns at an attractive cost. Exhibit one shows that the average passive fund tends to cost about 21 to 59 basis points less than the average active fund for asset classes commonly offered in DC schemes.

Unintended consequences of the charge cap

A charge cap of 0.75% for default funds used for auto enrolment was introduced in the UK in April 2015 to ensure pension scheme members are 'protected from high and unfair charges and are saving into schemes that are well run.'1 This charge cap spurred some schemes to implement low-cost investment options within the default fund. While it was not intended to do so, the introduction of the charge cap changed the investment selection paradigm for scheme trustees by focusing more on cost in isolation than on 'value for money'.

"What is ‘value for money'? Value for money is about finding the right balance between economy, efficiency and effectiveness, and cannot be assessed through only one of these dimensions in isolation." - Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)

 

Issued in the UK by MFS International (U.K.) Limited ("MIL UK"), a private limited company registered in England and Wales with the company number 03062718, and authorised and regulated in the conduct of investment business by the UK Financial Conduct Authority. MIL UK, an indirect subsidiary of MFS®, has its registered office at One Carter Lane, London, EC4V 5ER. 

More on Investment

Partner Insight: PIMCO Outlook - The fragmentation era

Partner Insight: PIMCO Outlook - The fragmentation era

With the world order in flux, investors can look to fortify portfolios by diversifying across global markets and capitalising on attractive, high-quality yields.

Richard Clarida, Andrew Balls and Daniel Ivascyn at PIMCO
clock 09 July 2025 • 10 min read
Now Pensions makes first private markets investment

Now Pensions makes first private markets investment

Supports ambition to invest at least 10% of its default fund in private market assets

Holly Roach
clock 07 July 2025 • 1 min read
Partner Insight: Managing investment risks in retirement

Partner Insight: Managing investment risks in retirement

The need to manage investment risks in retirement is more acute now than ever before. Recent stock market volatility and upside inflation risks from tariffs are once again focusing minds on the phenomenon known as sequencing risk.

Trevor Greetham, Head of Multi Asset at Royal London Asset Management
clock 07 July 2025 • 2 min read
Trustpilot