• Home
  • Admin/Tech
  • Benefits
  • Buzz
  • DB
  • DC
  • Diversity
  • Investment
  • Law & regulation
  • Risk reduction
  • Events
  • Whitepapers
  • Spotlights
  • Digital Edition
  • PPTV
  • Newsletters
  • Sign in
  •  
      • Newsletters
      • Account details
      • Contact support
      • Sign out
     
    •  

      You are currently accessing ProfessionalPensions via your Enterprise account.

      If you already have an account please use the link below to sign in.

      If you have any problems with your access or would like to request an individual access account please contact our customer service team.

      Phone: +44 (0) 1858 438800

      Email: [email protected]

      • Sign in
  • Follow us
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • Newsletters
    • YouTube
  • Register
  • Subscribe
  • Events
    • Upcoming events
      event logo
      Defined Benefit Consolidation Conference

      Professional Pensions is hosting this concise digital event on the 25th March to provide a crucial update on where the current regulation stands on DB Consolidators, assess the different models available, what the expected funding levels are and the governance requirements. This event will be a combination of short presentations followed by live Q&A’s with our expert speakers allowing plenty of time to answer your questions.

      • Date: 25 Mar 2021
      • Digital Conference
      event logo
      Defined Contribution Conference

      Professional Pensions Defined Contribution virtual event, hopes to take stock of the last year, and ask the important questions; are members saving enough and have we improved the member journey at retirement? This two part digital event will provide you with the latest thinking and innovation in the DC market during our snappy 15 minute presentations, with plenty of time to ask questions during our live speaker Q&A.

      • Date: 20 Apr 2021
      • Digital Conference
      event logo
      Sustainable Investment Festival 2021

      The Sustainable Investment Festival will run online from 22-25 June and will include thought-provoking presentations from renowned keynote speakers, innovative breakout events and sessions specifically tailored to meet the information needs of fund selectors, financial advisers, pension consultants, trustees and scheme managers.

      • Date: 22 Jun 2021
      • Online, Online
      event logo
      UK Pensions Awards 2021

      The UK Pensions Awards – now in their 24th year – remain the industry's most prestigious accolades. They shine the light on excellence and recognise the advisers, providers and investment managers that offer the highest level of innovation, performance and service to occupational pension schemes and their members, and have done the most to improve this over the past year.

      • Date: 14 Sep 2021
      • London
      View all events
      Follow our Professional Pension Events

      Sign up to receive email alerts about our events

      Sign up

  • Whitepapers
    • How DC schemes can gain exposure to different asset classes in a low-return environment

      So far, DC plans have largely been focused on the onset of auto-enrolment and changes to the regulatory framework - be it the ‘charge cap,' ‘pension freedoms' or consultations around ‘value for money', says Annabel Tonry, Executive Director at J.P. Morgan Asset Management (JPMAM).

      Download
      Pension freedoms three years on

      In 2015 George Osborne, then the UK Chancellor of the Exchequer, decided that those age over 55 could take much more of their pension in cash. This has since opened up a range of possibilities for DC scheme members in the world of pensions.

      Download
      Find whitepapers
      Search by title or subject area
      View all whitepapers
  • Spotlights
  • Digital Edition
Professional Pensions
Professional Pensions
Sponsored by T. Rowe Price
  • Home
  • Admin/Tech
  • Benefits
  • Buzz
  • DB
  • DC
  • Diversity
  • Investment
  • Law & regulation
  • Risk reduction
 
    • Newsletters
    • Account details
    • Contact support
    • Sign out
 
  •  

    You are currently accessing ProfessionalPensions via your Enterprise account.

    If you already have an account please use the link below to sign in.

    If you have any problems with your access or would like to request an individual access account please contact our customer service team.

    Phone: +44 (0) 1858 438800

    Email: [email protected]

    • Sign in
  • Law and Regulation

UPDATE 2: ECJ rules PPF compensation must amount to 50% of members' benefits

UPDATE 2: ECJ rules PPF compensation must amount to 50% of members' benefits
  • James Phillips
  • James Phillips
  • @PPJamesPhillips
  • 06 September 2018
  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  
0 Comments

At a glance:

  • ECJ ruling means compensation cap and pre-1997 indexation rules must be reviewed
  • Estimated impact on PPF liabilities amounts to just 1% or £215m
  • The judgment could also impact schemes which wound up outside the PPF

A landmark ruling in the European Court of Justice means the PPF must now revisit how it calculates members' benefits. James Phillips explores the impact.

The Pension Protection Fund (PPF) must ensure it pays out at least 50% of individual entitlements to members whose funds were absorbed into the lifeboat fund, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) has ruled.

In a judgment handed down this morning (6 September), the ECJ said current compensation levels were not always enough, heeding the official opinion of one of the court's advocate-generals that PPF benefits were "unlawful".

While benefits for non-pensioners are capped at 90% of £39,006, with no indexation link granted to pre-1997 benefits, this is illegal if it amounts to less than half of the members' original entitlement, the ECJ ruled.

It can also affect members of schemes who had post-1997 benefits linked to the retail prices index (RPI); in the PPF, these benefits are uprated in line with the consumer prices index (CPI).

PPF member Grenville Hampshire, who brought the case, was forced to accept a 67% cut to his pension entitlement when his former employer, Turner & Newall, went insolvent in 2006, prompting an assessment period for the company's scheme. This saw the value of his pension fall from £76,302 to £19,189 per year.

The case was brought on the grounds that PPF was incompatible with Article 8 of the European Union's Insolvency Directive, but the PPF and UK government had argued this did not apply.

However, the court today said: "In the event of the insolvency of their employer [the directive] must be interpreted as meaning that every individual employee must receive old-age benefits corresponding to at least 50% of the value of his accrued entitlement under a supplementary occupational pension scheme in the event of his employer's insolvency."

The judgment will have a resounding impact on the level of compensation some PPF members will receive, and could also affect schemes that wound up outside of the lifeboat fund with PPF-level benefits.

A PPF spokesperson said the lifeboat had been in discussions with the government to consider what changes will be necessary for PPF and Financial Assistance Scheme (FAS) compensation.

"We will work to implement the judgment as quickly as possible but first need to consider the judgment further to understand what action we can take prior to legislative change and the conclusion of the UK court proceedings," they said.

"Members can be reassured that we will update them further as soon as we are able."

A Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) spokesperson said the government respected the decision, adding: "This is a complex matter and the government and the PPF are carefully examining the judgment to determine precisely how best to implement it."

'Good news for higher earners'

Herbert Smith Freehills professional support lawyer Tim Smith said some beneficiaries would clearly benefit more than others by the judgment.

"This judgment is clearly good news for higher earners whose schemes have entered the PPF and who have seen their benefits cut significantly. The compensation levels payable under the PPF will now need to be reviewed. This will have an impact on the PPF's funding levels and may feed into future levy payments."

The number of people who will be impacted by the judgment is expected to be small, increasing PPF liabilities by an estimated total of 1% or £215m based on an interpretation where the PPF would review the present value of benefits, rather than annual payments, PP understands.

Pinsent Masons partner Stephen Scholefield said he was not surprised by the judgment as it chimes with previous rulings by the ECJ on similar issues, and added that the most interesting aspect was that the PPF will have to apply the ruling on an ongoing basis.

"The issue for a lot of people is not so much the effect of the compensation cap, but the combination of the cap and the loss of pension increases on pre-1997 pensions," he said. "Both of those aspects together can drop you under 50% but sometimes the pension increases are as significant as the cap over time.

"It's clear the PPF is going to have to change the way it operates."

However, recent promises by the PPF about how it distributes its funding will now have to be reviewed, said Royal London director of policy Sir Steve Webb. The lifeboat fund's chief executive, Oliver Morley, recently indicated any surplus could be used to enhance members' benefits and reduce levy payments.

"Given that the PPF has spoken about what to do with its surplus funds, a priority must be given to address the position of people such as Mr. Hampshire who could find themselves receiving less than half their pension due to the limited nature of the PPF."

Trustees face mismatch

Scholefield called on the government to legislate clearly and quickly both to help the PPF understand how it should now calculate compensation, while also bringing clarification over a "mismatch" that will now be faced by trustees.

"The difficulty for most schemes now is there's a mismatch between what the PPF is required to do, which is comply with this 50% minimum rule, and what trustees are required to do if they are sufficiently well-funded to wind up outside the PPF.

"Trustees have to comply with section 73 of the Pensions Act 1995, which says that when you secure benefits outside the PPF, the first tranche must mirror PPF benefits, but it refers very specifically to them as set out in legislation. Trustees are now going to have this dilemma of do they follow the legislation that says apply the cap and the restricted increases, or are they going to somehow choose to override that on the basis that the legislation is now looking a bit defective?"

It is likely the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) and PPF would now need to reconsider how schemes calculate their section 179 position - the valuation used to calculate the cost of insuring benefits at PPF-levels.

For these schemes, "there is a real issue as to precisely how do you secure these benefits," Scholefield added. "Schemes deserve a fairly clear statement from the government."

Smith agreed these problems could arise, noting: "The position of underfunded schemes that have narrowly missed out on PPF entry and also those schemes that have secured benefits outside the PPF on a PPF-plus basis will also need to be considered in light of this judgment."

Legislation urgent

The government also needs to answer the question as to whether the rule will be backdated, Scholefield added. Although, as Brexit nears, he said it would be unlikely for the government to hold out and not implement the legislation.

Pensions and Lifetime Savings Association head of defined benefit, local government pension schemes, and standards Joe Dabrowski agreed legislation needs to be brought forward urgently.

"The ruling today clarifies the minimum level of protection that pension savers can expect from the PPF and FAS following their employer's insolvency," he said. "It is important, nonetheless, that clarity is swiftly provided for affected individuals.

"If legislative changes are required to enable the PPF to provide the correct levels of compensation and assistance, then we'd like to see these brought forward as soon as possible by the DWP."

The matter was referred from the Court of Appeal and will now be remitted back to the court to end UK proceedings.

Although the case has not officially come to an end, the next steps are now procedural, with the PPF required to implement the ruling as soon as possible.

  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  
  • Topics
  • Law and Regulation
  • Pension Protection Fund
  • PPF
  • European Court of Justice
  • Grenville Hampshire
  • Pinsent Masons
  • Stephen Scholefield
  • Herbert Smith Freehills
  • Tim Smith
  • PLSA
  • Pensions and Lifetime Savings Association
  • Joe Dabrowski
  • financial assistance scheme
  • FAS

More on Law and Regulation

Smith: It is only fair that DB schemes pay the most as this is where most of the regulator’s energy is focused
DWP confirms general levy hike from April; Option one chosen

The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has confirmed that it will increase the general levy pension rates from April 2021 in line with its preferred option.

  • Law and Regulation
  • 05 March 2021
The consultation closed in 2019
DWP delays consultation response on trustee oversight of investment consultants

The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has delayed further a consultation response and final regulations to enact requirements relating to investment consultants.

  • Law and Regulation
  • 03 March 2021
Opperman: We are now progressing secondary legislation to ensure the UK’s pension system is safer, better and greener
Pensions minister sets out timetable for Pension Schemes Act regulations

Pensions minister Guy Opperman has set out a timetable for secondary legislation to bring Pension Schemes Act provisions into force.

  • Law and Regulation
  • 03 March 2021
What a ban on corporate directors could mean for schemes

Shane O'Reilly and Julia Chirnside look at how a government proposal could put professional trustees in breach of the law.

  • Law and Regulation
  • 03 March 2021
The investigation is the second of its three-part inquiry and the Committee said it concluded taking evidence for its first part in January.
MPs to investigate advice in ongoing pensions freedoms inquiry

MPs on the Work and Pensions Committee (WPC) will assess the availability of financial advice in the second stage of its pensions freedom inquiry.

  • Law and Regulation
  • 23 February 2021
blog comments powered by Disqus
Back to Top

Most read

Spring Budget 2021: Lifetime allowance freeze, flat rate of tax relief and AE review among expectations
Spring Budget 2021: Lifetime allowance freeze, flat rate of tax relief and AE review among expectations
Spring Budget 2021: Lifetime allowance frozen until 2026
Spring Budget 2021: Lifetime allowance frozen until 2026
KPMG employer covenant team acquired by private equity firm H.I.G Europe
KPMG employer covenant team acquired by private equity firm H.I.G Europe
DB funding - February 2021: Gilts-plus deficit eliminated, says PwC
DB funding - February 2021: Gilts-plus deficit eliminated, says PwC
Spring Budget 2021: Government to consult again on DC investments and charge cap barriers
Spring Budget 2021: Government to consult again on DC investments and charge cap barriers
Trustpilot

 

  • Contact Us
  • Marketing solutions
  • About Incisive Media
  • Terms and conditions
  • Policies
  • Careers
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Newsletters
  • YouTube

© Incisive Business Media (IP) Limited, Published by Incisive Business Media Limited, New London House, 172 Drury Lane, London WC2B 5QR, registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 09177174 & 09178013

Digital publisher of the year
Digital publisher of the year 2010, 2013, 2016 & 2017
Loading