Rory Murphy, trustee chairman of the Merchant Navy Officers Pension Fund (MNOPF), says trustees must do more to share best practice in bid to improve outcomes.
I fully support any move by the regulatory authorities to improve clarity and competition in the investment consultancy industry, including the Financial Conduct Authority's (FCA's) decision to refer the industry to the Competition and Markets Authority.
However, it would be simplistic to pin the entire responsibility for any shortcomings on the consultants. The FCA's own academic research identifies a number of factors that can lead to trustees "being unwilling or unable to challenge consultants, and therefore to accept strategies they do not fully understand". As a pension fund trustee, I find this just as worrying as any weaknesses in the consultancy industry.
Many schemes have achieved great results by implementing a rigorous and effective governance structure, by challenging their advisors, and ensuring they are absolutely clear on every point when making critical strategic decisions. In striving for better outcomes, greater sharing of best practice among the broader trustee community could play as valuable a role as any regulatory intervention.
Ultimately, any trustee who fails to ask questions, or goes along with decisions without fully understanding them, is failing the very people whose interests are at the core of this issue - namely, the members of their pension schemes.
Rory Murphy is trustee chairman of the Merchant Navy Officers Pension Fund
Aggregate spending on defined benefit (DB) pensions has dropped from £19bn to £15bn in 12 months, according to Hymans Robertson.
Every month, several firms issue trackers of the aggregate defined benefit (DB) scheme funding position. See here for the November 2019 estimates on the various measures…
Pension scheme trustees should actively engage financial advisers if members are looking to transfer out of their defined benefit arrangements and washing their hands of the process does not eliminate risk, a study has found.
Unilever has set out plans to overhaul its defined benefit (DB) pension arrangements in a bid to manage costs.
A typical defined benefit (DB) scheme was able to meet 93.7% of its accrued pension rights as of 30 September this year, according to Legal & General Investment Management (LGIM).