Standard Life and Zurich unveil IGC reports

Jonathan Stapleton
Zurich received an amber rating from its IGC

Zurich received an amber rating from its IGC

Standard Life and Zurich have published their latest independent governance committee (IGC) reports – posting overall green and amber value-for-money assessments respectively.

In his introduction to the annual report for Standard Life's workplace personal pensions, IGC independent chairman David Hare said that, while the IGC believed that Standard Life continued to offer value for money to members, it had some concerns over customer communications and engagement and the application of ESG principles to investment - areas it had ranked as ‘green with a hint of amber' and ‘amber with a hint of green' respectively.

In the report, the IGC said it found that, while statistics of customer satisfaction with communications were strong, there were lower levels of satisfaction from customers that they have the information they need to make decisions on their pension and investments.

It said it was also "disappointed" at a lack of visibility of how ESG considerations impact in-scope members' funds, despite repeated requests from the IGC, but noted this had been countered by the development of group-wide sustainability and responsible Investment initiatives that are starting to address many of its concerns.

Zurich's IGC report noted that, as most of Zurich's modern pensions had moved to Scottish Widows during 2019, it was now largely only focussed on older-style pensions. It noted it had given Zurich an amber rating for value for money, the same as last year.

IGC chairwoman Anna Bradley explained: "It is our opinion that progress has been made this year and Zurich has improved value for money. It also has plans in place to make further improvements. However, progress is slower than we would like. Some improvements currently apply to only a small sub-set of members while Zurich try new things out. In a few cases, we have been disappointed by the length of time it has taken Zurich to respond to some of our challenges. We are looking for a wider and speedier response in the future and have raised this with management."

More on Risk Reduction

Bulk annuity providers neglect UK Stewardship Code

Bulk annuity providers neglect UK Stewardship Code

Insurers make errors on if the code applies to them, despite general ESG progress

James Phillips
clock 13 January 2022 • 2 min read
Standard Life managing director of defined benefit solutions Justin Grainger

Imperial Tobacco in £1.8bn buy-in with Standard Life

Biggest buy-in of 2021 so far is Standard Life’s largest deal as business ramps up

James Phillips
clock 13 January 2022 • 3 min read
Updated: The biggest buy-ins and buyouts since 2007

Updated: The biggest buy-ins and buyouts since 2007

Professional Pensions rounds up the largest block transfers of liabilities to insurers

Professional Pensions
clock 13 January 2022 • 1 min read